Around the three-hour mark of the Pulitzer Prize-winning Broadway play August: Osage County, the matriarch of the dysfunctional family decides to cut through all the BS. “It’s time for some truth-tellin’,” she says.
Same here at Point Blank. I’ve always tried to have an open dialogue with our readers, but I feel like it’s been a while. The time is now because it’s been a few weeks since the end of the season and the rhetoric in the Comments space and in the emails has intensified to the point where I want to address some issues.
This is going to be long, long-winded, blunt, defensive and maybe at times offensive to a few of you. Just putting it all out there, folks. I will cover a whole range of topics, so pull up a chair and bear with me. Thanks.
Sponsors: You may see some ads on the site over the next few days. Our hope is to prove the value of the blog to potential sponsors. I would be indebted if you would please click on these ads from every computer you have access to, patronize the sponsors and spread the word. It could go a long way in keeping us running longer.
Support Drive: There’s a likelihood that if the blog continues into next hockey season, I will run a support drive in the form of a deal on tickets to one or two Islanders games during the season. Consider it (hopefully) one giant Point Blank group sales night. Perhaps it’s an opportunity for many of you to meet up at a game. I understand some readers may be season ticketholders and many are not from New York, but I certainly would appreciate the support of anyone in position to get involved.
PB Night III: If we’re back for another season, it’s a lock that the next Point Blank Night will be at R.C. Dugan’s on Hempstead Turnpike in East Meadow. Thank you, Jay, for your dedication to the cause.
“Conflicts”: I realize some of you missed this when I wrote about it in the early days of the blog, or did not see when I spoke about it with C.J. Papa on the Islanders telecast. So that there’s no misunderstanding, let me make a few things perfectly clear.
The idea for Point Blank came from Islanders President Chris Dey about a month or so after I left the organization last May 5. The team and the sport was in need of more coverage. Fans hungered for non-stop reporting on the Islanders and Dey wanted to deliver it to them. I was available! It was Dey who understood that it would only work if the blog was run independently of the team. For the record, Dey has stood by his end of the bargain, and I applaud him and am thankful to him for it.
The New York Islanders are the primary sponsor of Point Blank. Newsday refers to PB as the “team-sponsored blog” – as opposed to the Rangers-sponsored newspaper – and I’ve never hid from that.
Some facts: the Islanders have never asked me to write a story or not write a story. The first time Islanders management sees a post is the same as you: when it’s published on the site. I’ve never been asked to take down a reader Comment about members of the organization, and there have been plenty of vicious ones.
In 2009, more than three-quarters of sports journalism is touched by some conflict of interest. Leagues are in bed with networks. Writers from major magazines and newspapers serve as paid talking heads on league-owned networks. Two of New York’s top sports radio voices receive checks from the companies that own major league sports teams. Sportswriters have publishing deals with the coaches and athletes they are supposed to cover.
Long Island’s newspaper is owned by the company that owns the Knicks, Rangers, Madison Square Garden and MSG Network. Neil Best, one of the finest media columnists in the U.S. and a man of impeccable honor, covers one of the major holdings of his boss. So do the Newsday writers on the Knicks and Rangers. Wally Matthews blistered Charles Wang last summer, has plenty of tough opinions on the Steinbrenners and at times has been vicious toward Jeff Wilpon. As for the Dolans, Wally doesn’t seem to have much to say.
I stand by the facts I’ve written, and the opinions that have come from the heart and the mind.
Town of Hempstead: Before I ever wrote my first critical word of Kate Murray’s handling of the Lighthouse Project, I called Town spokesman Mike Deery three times and left him three voicemails. I attempted to start a professional relationship, but the Town did not have the time nor the interest for this blogger and resident. I don’t expect them to ever want to deal with me now. Should the Town of Hempstead ever make its first right move – like maybe Murray showing up at a meeting – I’ll be the first to praise it.
For now, that Islanders Fan First website and mailer fiasco – the project they aborted after three days – remains the Town’s signature moment. To those of you who believe I just get my kicks bashing the Republican side of this issue, you don’t know anything about me or my other projects. By writing the facts, and writing what I feel, in this brutal economy I’m potentially costing myself income from some of the PR consultant jobs I’ve been up for. That’s about as far as I can take it.
My Background: Other than knowing I worked for the team for a while, understandably most of you don’t know my background and how it relates to the blog. So here’s a bit about my career in the game.
In my senior year in college, I worked full-time for the Philadelphia Flyers in the 1986-87 season, the year they went to Game 7 of the Stanley Cup Final. Along the way, the Flyers defeated the Rangers, Islanders (right after the Easter Epic) and Montreal before Wayne Gretzky took over in the final period of the deciding game in the Final. I did not get a Cup ring, but I made countless friends and contacts with the Flyers and around the league, most of them still in the business.
Six months later, I was hired by the Islanders to edit a monthly newspaper, Islander News. Among those on my first Islanders team: Trottier, Bossy, Denis Potvin, LaFontaine, Brent Sutter, Morrow, Flatley, Billy Smith and Kelly Hrudey. Along the way, I managed the team’s publications, sold group tickets and even served as radio color commentator for a year and a half after Bob Nystrom left the job (yup, it was a major step down in the booth, but I tried). I went into PR fulltime in the mid-90s, was named VP in 1999 and stayed in that position for 9 years.
So many of the players and coaches on those early Islanders teams are spread out around the league as scouts, coaches and broadcasters and remain good friends and invaluable contacts. On the 1992-93 team alone, former players are now near the top of directories with NHL teams and the Players Association. My favorite time was working for Al Arbour and the ’92-93 team, the second was the mini-revival in 2001-02 under Peter Laviolette and watching the Coliseum come alive again.
For more than a decade, I managed a press box that hosted scouts from every team in the league and elsewhere. Most of those relationships are still in place today. Naturally, I’m still in contact with many of my former colleagues in the Islanders front office.
So when I rank prospects, I may not always be bang-on, but understand I’m not throwing paper darts into the wind. When I write that the majority of scouts I’ve spoken with say Drew Doughty will have a better NHL career than Victor Hedman, it could ultimately be wrong, but I’m not listening to the voices inside my head. I’m a reporter who listens to dozens of men who do this for a living. Turns out the amateur scouts on the Point Blank speed dial knew almost all season Matt Duchene was 2 or 3, even when The Hockey News had him at 6.
Blog Stats: With each month, the Page Views and Visits for Point Blank grew in leaps and bounds, peaking (of course) in March with Gueringate. The drama got so big, the numbers on Sunday – when everyone thought Bill was going to be traded – actually were better than the day of the Trade Deadline.
The really good news is that the stats in April barely dropped off. Lottery day was a good one, but it was so gratifying to see all the new readers we picked up in March seem to be sticking around.
When you consider the Islanders did not play an important game for the purposes of playoff contention since the holidays, the numbers have been remarkable. The credit goes to you for your dedication to this team and for spreading the word about the blog.
Comments: One of the reasons why the Page Views of Point Blank have grown beyond my expectations is because of your efforts in the Comments space. I spoke with a top guy at NHL Security the other day who told me he is as interested in reading all the Comments as my blog entries. I wasn’t offended. That’s the way it should be on a good blog.
If many of you believe I’m a nut about moderating the Comments space, I take the hit but also have no regrets. We have all seen how the blogs of many talented writers have been almost destroyed by the nonsense that goes on in the Comments. I refuse to let that happen. For everyone I’ve ticked off, I still believe the Comment Guidelines are a vital reason why the site tends to get at least 100 legitimate, passionate, insightful Comments (and often a lot more) after each story. I want as many readers as possible to feel like they can share their opinions.
On criticism of my work, I have no problem when a reader disagrees with me, tears me apart or even plays the ever-popular shill card. (The son of a friend of mine posted from his college dorm a while ago that I was still Garth’s boy). I love that stuff.
To be candid, the only ones I find personally annoying are the ones that say something like, “I don’t care about this subject” or “Don’t you have anything better to write about”? One of my favorites was when I broke the news the Islanders had signed third round pick Mark Katic and a regular reader of an Islanders blog said he didn’t care and it was just “fodder.”
If you are the kind of person who actually takes the time to post on an Islanders blog that you don’t care about stories on Mike Bossy, Kirill Petrov, Denis Potvin, the Lighthouse – after all, it only determines the team’s future – prospects and small anecdotes from behind-the-scenes, I encourage you to go somewhere else for your daily Islanders reading.
Now that we’ve been at this seven months and I have regularly asked readers to review the Comment Guidelines, I’m done with warnings. If you go off-topic, write not a comment but a full-blown blog entry, post more than 3 per thread, are profane, call your fellow readers “idiots” and “morons” and the ever-popular “___ clowns” or give me other reasons to be cautious, your Comment posts are going to moderation. If you’d like to address this issue, please send me an email so we can work it out one-on-one.
Effective today, while some readers may have their Comments go to moderation, no one is on permanent block any longer.
The Year in Review: After working for the team for so long, I was more comfortable transitioning to the media side than I expected. It probably helped that there was a new head coach and some key players (including Doug Weight) that I had never worked with.
Scott Gordon and I didn’t have much to do with each other for about two months mid-season. He didn’t like some stuff I wrote. I didn’t like the way he handled it, so I passed on many of his media scrums because he wasn’t saying much. In the final 4-6 weeks of the season, the working relationship improved. I stubbornly believe Scott has a few things he needs to work on. He stubbornly thinks I’m wrong and everything is okay. Scott works his tail off, is extremely bright and is a very talented coach. Time will tell how it works out.
Garth Snow was irritated with me for a few weeks, primarily because I wrote my 8-year old twins did a better job of staying on the same page as the Islanders were on the Rick DiPietro injury stuff. The Islanders stood by their version of the story. Over time, we moved on. As I wrote when I was in timeout, I do not need complete access to write the blog. When you shut out the media, it usually hurts the team more – especially when that team does not boast bountiful coverage. Felt the same way when I was the PR director.
I especially want to mention youngsters Josh Bailey and Kyle Okposo for their professionalism during a difficult season. Think about Bailey. He knew about the immediate fan and press reaction when the team went from 5 to 7 to 9 and drafted him. I wrote that he should go to juniors, and then to the World Junior Championships. Yet through it all, he answered the questions and handled himself like a 15-year pro. My experience tells me that’s a good sign.
All of the veterans were very good with the press, most notably for me Weight, Brendan Witt and Richard Park. The team’s PR staff – Seth Sylvan, Corey Witt and young Josh Bernstein – are good men and made me feel comfortable in my new gig. I thank them for that.
Other than a few hours one Sunday early on when we battled over the “team-sponsored” thing, Greg Logan and I got along really well. He is a friend, and I have learned a lot from him. The days when Dan Martin of the Post and Peter Botte of the Daily News attend practice are always good days.
I also want to thank the MSG Network crew for putting me on the pre-game show and Howie Rose and Billy Jaffe for mentioning Point Blank more than a few times. Same to Steve Mears and Chris King for their support on the radio side and their assistance. Thank you to Lisa and the moderators at Islandermania for always linking to my stories. That’s a huge help, and especially was early on when the blog was trying to get off the ground. Thank you to Roseanne and the crew at Gabrielle’s for their amazing generosity as our unofficial watering hole.
In the world outside the Islanders, thank you to Don La Greca for guiding this novice on ESPN Radio. Thank you to Hofstra University for the opportunity to see if I can teach. Thank you to Stan Bratskeir for his PR guru-ness.
Thank you to Kevin Schultz of Barry Melrose Rocks for getting behind the Gran Torino when I had to step away. Thank you to B.D. Gallof for his help in the early days and best of luck with his new venture. Whatever happened in between, I wish him well in doing his best to make sure it doesn’t happen again.
Future: As of this date, there’s a commitment to write this blog until the NHL Draft in late June. After that, I do not have any guarantees. It is my sincere wish to run Point Blank for at least another year and hopefully a lot more beyond that. I hope to know in the next few weeks if I’ll be around past June. For now, please click the heck out of any sponsor ads you may see.
One thing is certain: the only way I will ever do this blog is if I’m provided the opportunity to cover the Islanders 24/7/365. From time to time readers suggest that if I move into another full-time career that I pop in and write once or twice a week. This franchise has been my life’s work and a bit of an obsession now for 21 years. When I worked for the Islanders, I thought about my responsibilities every hour for two decades. It’s impossible for me to picture doing this blog half-way. In fact, I’m sure I will never do it that way.
One more time, thank you to all of the Point Blank readers for checking out the site, sharing your insight, passing along your knowledge and keeping me in line. Here’s hoping we can keep this going for a long time.
Since I went long, the 100-word limit is waived for this Comments section – as long as you stay on topic!
I need to take a personal day, maybe two, so I will miss the U.S.-Russia game on Friday morning. Unless there is any breaking Islanders news, I’ll be off the laptop. I’m sure Greg and the Times blog, among other sites, will be on the Worlds.
Please feel free to submit any questions you may have related to this post and I will address as many as I can as soon as I return. Thanks…CB